Moho Forum

What type of adobe photoshop should an ametuer photographer buy? I want to buy photoshop for my computer, but there are so many different types of photoshop I don't know what to buy! I was planning on getting it on ebay cheap but some photoshops are a little too cheap. What are student versions and how do I know what is the best for me. Please help!
_____________________
keyword research ~ keyword tool ~ keyword tracking ~ affiliate elite

It depends on what you need to do with your photos.

Photoshop Elements is very very basic. If all you need is simple color adjustments then it would work for you. If you are a "traditional" old school type of photographer looking to clean up or adjust your photos Elements is going to have what you need. But if you plan to create extensive photo montages, special effects type photo manipulations you would be better off with Photoshop CS5 which is available now (just released) it has more advanced features for photo manipulation, filters, effects etc.

Photoshop Extended I believe has some animation and 3D capabilities. But these are limited and there probably are much better tools for that type of thing.

Try out Elements. It's more affordable and may be all you need. If you need more you can update it later.

Check the features of the different versions. You should seriously consider getting the one that allows for "raw" camera format editing and the high resolution editing of photos. Not too familar with it myself doing mostly web work, but this format for photography has a huge dynamic range for extremely high quality photo work. As a photographer this would probably be very important. I am not sure which one of the Photoshop versions has this capability. I doubt that Elements has it.


You may even want to look at other options such as Gimp which is free (open source). I use Gimp right now since I can't afford Photoshop CS and it is very similar and even opens PSD files.

I can suggest you Artweaver.
It's a good "clone" of photoshop and supports .ABR brushes.
And you can find lots of free plugin 'cause it use LUA scripting.
Plus, the base version are free and the pro will cost 29,99$.

I find it more handly than the "original" photoshop.


P.S.
The 1.x version has a little ABR import bug, you can solve with this workaround:
http://forum.artweaver.de/viewtopic.php ... 1456#p4592

Try Gimp, It's free and dose things similar to PhotoShop elements. I use both, one works better than the other according to what you are doing.

Dale

dueyftw wrote:Try Gimp, It's free and dose things similar to PhotoShop elements. I use both, one works better than the other according to what you are doing.

Dale

I think Gimp is a bit confusing...

Yes, Gimp is WAY different from photoshop. I am slowly climbing the learning curve. However I am FORCING myself to "relearn" image editing using Gimp (at least until I can afford Photoshop for my new Mac). The issue that I've noticed is not that Gimp is "hard" but that it is "different". That makes it hard to get the hang of it.

The main drawback to Gimp is the palettes or windows. When switching applications and going back to Gimp the windows and palettes don't come to the front. I have to select the windows. There's a focus issue.

-vern

uhm... guys, I think josefina is a robot

I just noticed that the original post was edited to add the links. What a bummer. I hate getting fooled.

-vern

selgin wrote:uhm... guys, I think josefina is a robot

She seemed like such a nice girl -- but her voice *was* a bit monotonous...

Bots are getting smarter?

This sucks, !@#$%^&

Dale

Actually probably not a "bot" in the traditional sense. Yes, they are getting smarter... because the spammers now hire live people to spam forums. Easiest way to get around captchas. Just as tech support and other services are outsourced to cheap labor so now is spamming.

-vern